I have wrestled with my rating for this brick of a book. On one hand, Meyer really is not the greatest writer out there, and I noticed it here. And Edward really is so controlling that it's frightening at times. And Bella can be nauseatingly gushy. Yes, I'm looking at the sentence, "I wrenched the door out of my way--ridiculously eager--and there he was, my personal miracle." Ugh. Cue the eye-rolling and gagging. But once I just sort of let that go and went with the story, I read most of this 629-page book today. I couldn't look away. So it would be 3 stars for all the things that irritated me, but I'm bumping it up to 4 stars for being compulsively readable.
And that really sums it up. That and I think the epilogue was a cheat to keep all the Jacob fans reading the series. I'll declare myself to be a member of Team Jacob right here. Edward, when he isn't being creepy, is just too perfect. He's enough to give a girl an inferiority complex. Give me Jacob's wild emotions any time.
Reviewed November 15, 2009
I hope those of you who are bigger fans than I am enjoy the movie!